Tuesday, November 9, 2010

TPF 11 - 09.11.10 - The Self and The Tribe - Nietzsche

TPF 11 - 09.11.10 - The Self and The Tribe - Nietzsche
Please email me philosophyfix@gmail.com if you want to be on the email list.
(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last night I met with an philosophy professor of mine over some beers (the best way to philosophize). A conversation occurred on the topic of politics, identity, people getting pulled into systems of power, and how people are afraid to rock the boat. The conversation circled around this question of when to be oneself as an individual and when to work with a group; an interesting ethical question in itself. We all agreed to that to some level people wish to be accepted by a larger group, but often that seems to also distance people from themselves.

Well, this morning I had a little bit of time and so I do what I normally have a few minutes here and there, I picked up a book by Nietzsche and began to peruse. I came across this quote:

"The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself." - Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900, German Philosopher).

I posted it to facebook and got some interesting and insightful responses. The professor I had beers with commented that it was refreshing there is more of a middle ground so one does not need to be as isolated as Nietzsche. Others' questioned if it was actually the case there was much space in between the two sides.

So, after not writing this fix in a long time, I was inspired to think about the balancing pendulum between the self and the self within a group. I think Nietzsche may have this wrong (shocking, I would say this), but I don't think he gives enough credence to other subjective realities and how they impact our identity creation. I agree with the fundamental view of not losing oneself among the tribe, but I am curious if we are also not defined by the tribe. This led me to some questions, which is where I will leave it for today:

- Is the (self) constructed as much by our own self as by others we relate to?
- Is it innate (ontological) to humans to be in relation to others?
- How is it that one can feel so alone and isolated while surrounded by others?