Showing posts with label Matrix. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matrix. Show all posts

Monday, January 11, 2010

TPF 9 - 11.1.10 - What is a good movie? - Zizek


Please email me philosophyfix@gmail.com if you want to be on the email list.

(
http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Last week I was sitting at Cheer Monday with a bunch of my friends and we were discussing movies, both good movies and bad movies. As it often goes when movies get discussed in a group; a debate erupted about whether a specific movie was good or not. The consequence of this was people attempting to convince the group that the movie they liked or disliked was good or not. This brings me to an area of philosophy that I have done very little with, Aesthetics. One of the most known works on Aesthetics is Critique of Judgement, by Immanual Kant. Aesthetics is the study of beauty, art and taste; so in this context the discussion revolved around the aesthetics of a movie, what people thought was a good movie.

"Cinema is the ultimate pervert art. It doesn't give you what you desire - it tells you how to desire." - Slavoj Žižek (Continental Philosopher, 1949 - Present)

Zizek doesn't offer the foundational analysis of taste in aesthetics that Kant does; he is interested in interpreting meaning of movies and what are movies attempting to do in relationship to our fictional world and reality (foreground and background). He argues that the fictional world is required for us to have reality; and without the fictional world reality would not exist for the human experience (which is why he critiques the Matrix's Blue Pill vs. Red Pill and wants a third pill).

The reason I chose Zizek for today is that I felt he offers a very interesting post-modern view of cinema and politics. And that is exactly what was happening in my discussion last Monday. There was a political aspect to the discussion of what was a good movie. The context of the film, when we saw the film, where we saw the film, what was happening in our lives when we saw the film. This led me to ask the question: "Have you seen a movie that changed your life? If so, what movie?"

The answers were very interesting as they corresponded deeply with where the viewer was situated in their life when they saw the movie. In some cases, a life changing film did not necessarily correspond with the viewer thinking the movie was a good move or one of the best movies. In some cases, while the movie was life changing (upon reflection) the movie was perceived to be silly or not very good.

This got me thinking about Zizek's quote and what makes a good movie. Is a good movie a movie that changes us? Is a good movie something that allows us to escape reality for a bit into the fictional? Is a good movie something that simply entertains? Or is a good movie, a movie that a viewer can relate to? According to Zizek, it is the human experience to have all these intersect.

- What movie, if any, has changed your life? Is it a good movie?
- Is a movie that is good today, necessarily good in a year, five years, or ten years? Or is it situated in its socio-historical context?
- How would you define "Movie of the year?" What qualities would be important?

As a side note, Zizek has a documentary out called The Pervert's Guide to Cinema and, in my opinion, has a great assessment and commentary of the movie Children of Men.