Showing posts with label flash forward. Show all posts
Showing posts with label flash forward. Show all posts

Saturday, January 9, 2010

TPF 8 - 9.1.10 - Determinism and seeing the future

(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I have been watching the TV Series Flash Forward. If you haven't watched it, I would highly suggest you watch it; as it grapples beautifully with the issue of Determinism vs. Free Will. The show is the investigation of a world wide phenomena where every human collapsed at the exact same time for a little over two minutes. During these two minutes people had flash forwards to six months in the future and experienced those two minutes in the future. When everyone re-awoke the flash forwards all corresponded with one another, meaning if I saw you in my flash forward playing baseball then you were playing baseball in your flash forward and saw me.

I appreciate shows that bring philosophical issues to the fore front; which this show has done. It brings to question, which each character struggles with in their own way, how would one live if they knew the outcome of their lives? By seeing the future in six months, does that necessitate that while we experience our lives as making choices; in reality we are actually just responding to stimulus in a predictable manner?

"There is no mind absolute or free will, but the mind is determined for willing this or that by a cause which is determined in its turn by another cause, and this one again by another, and so on to infinity." - Baruch Spinoza (Dutch Philosopher, 1632-1677).

Spinoza is arguing that human actions are done due to the proceeding circumstances, not due to intent or agency. Spinoza, in this sense, is a hard determinism in his argument that purpose of action is an illusion and instead individuals act purely out of proceeding occurrences that cause what an individual will do.

Flash Forward does an interesting job of spinning this philosophical discussion by changing the way in which we would look at determinism. Normally, the question hinges around if we are able to figure out the human machine well enough; we then will be able to ascertain what a person will do given their history by causation. The TV Show instead takes determinism as a plausible position by projecting a future (which is shared among all members of the world, giving it legitimacy and a sense of reality) in which defines where a person will be. The struggle the characters ensue after this is questioning what is it that will lead them to that future? I found it interesting in the show that some individuals lost motivation knowing their future and other gained motivation from knowing their future.

- Is the ability to determine a humans behavior reducible to their previous experiences?
- If you saw your future and you had evidence that it was legitimate; would it change the way you lived?