Please email me philosophyfix@gmail.com if you want to be on the email list.
(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I was down at the lighting of the Christmas Tree in downtown Portland when there was a man planning a bombing who was arrested in his attempt. Since the release of the news of the planned bombing, the conversation turned from the fear of the bombing to whether or not it was entrapment. Also in recent news is the release of classified documents on WikiLeaks. And after a Denial of Service attack (an attempt to bring down WikiLeaks), Amazon stepped up to provide bandwidth to be quickly shut down by political pressure from the US.
What does this have to do with Philosophy? About a week ago I posted on Facebook: "What have you done today to be political?" and was surprised to get so little responses (I believe three). We live in a world where being in the world is political itself.
- Do you react to Amazon hosting WikiLeaks and do not make a purchase from them?
- Do you decide to stay away from downtown Portland due to fear of a bombing?
- Do you tell others that Mohamed Mohamud is a "terrorist" or an entrapped naive student? All these are political acts.
- Do you believe that Julian Assange is a threat to world at this point or acting as a journalist?
What amazes me as I read postings and articles is the fervor on either side and the usage of rhetoric to inflame the emotions towards actions even more. This brings me to today's quote by Caesar:
"Beware the leader who bangs the drums of war in order to whip the citizenry into a patriotic fervor, for patriotism is indeed a double-edged sword. It both emboldens the blood, just as it narrows the mind. And when the drums of war have reached a fever pitch and the blood boils with hate and the mind has closed, the leader will have no need in seizing the rights of the citizenry. Rather, the citizenry, infused with fear and blinded by patriotism, will offer up all of their rights unto the leader and gladly so. How do I know? For this is what I have done. And I am Caesar."
- Julius Caesar (Roman General, 100 BC - 44 BC)
I do not propose to have answers on whether or not WikiLeaks has behaved ethically. Nor do I have the answer of whether or not Mohamed Mohamud was entrapped, a terrorist, or something completely different. What I do know is that Caeser, over 2000 years ago, knew something that seems lost on contemporary citizens. That is to leave your fervor at the door when being political and that we are being political all the time. I have been asked why I am critical of Democracy and the news in the last two days is the reason. There is little discourse occurring and a lot of rhetoric. In my opinion, Democracy requires discourse and thought; not simple persuasion. I find it interesting that in a "land of the free" (an example of political rhetoric) our government uses political pressure to silence a free market company (Amazon). This leads me to ask lots of questions, but I will just leave a few here:
- What makes someone a terrorist (or a freedom fighter)? Who decides?
- How is the censoring of WikiLeaks by the US different than the censoring of media by the Chinese government?
- Is it human nature to be emotionally political and if so, is Democracy a safe political system given the horrific potential of human behavior when purely emotionally driven?
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
Thursday, December 17, 2009
TPF 4 - 17.12.09 - Punishment
In the process of coming up with this fix, a friend of mine said he hoped that I wouldn't just use the same philosophers that I always quote (Nietzsche, Sartre, etc.) but instead branch out more and quote other philosophers. This poses one benefit and one challenge. The benefit is that I get an opportunity to go read philosophers I am not acquainted with as well (like in yesterday's TPF). The challenge is that philosophy is built upon philosophy. As I read over a few books today, I realized that the amount of name dropping and reference to other philosophers is quite common. Originally I had hoped to write about the stalling tactics today in the Senate and specifically in the context of authenticity. While an interesting topic and one worth exploration, I chose not to because most of the references I wanted to quote referenced many other philosophers. So today, I am going to write about how philosophy is still alive and in a very real way.
"A conception of punishment as a social practice within a community, geared towards the pursuit of (which entails respect for) a plurality of the community’s central goals and values, moderate in its severity, and with an importantly symbolic aspect. It has both particular (preventive, deterrent and so on) and general (support of the community and its framework values) functions... In constructing the community conception of punishment, despite our relaxation of certain important liberal assumptions and our rejection of some central liberal values, we have been able to preserve and utilise important aspects of the arguments about legal and political obligation and the nature of the criminal law set out in the earlier chapters which integrated the question of punishment in its proper political context." - Nicola Lacey (Professor of Criminal Law and Legal Theory at the London School of Economics).
Before I get into Lacey's quote, I want to point out that this philosopher is alive, teaching and writing at the London School of Economics, although she does not have a Wikipedia page yet. I was introduced to her by chance and read a book by her State Punishment: Political Principles and Community Values.
Lacey's primary argument, as indicated in the quote, is a turn from looking at the need of punishment in a society from an individual focus to a community focus. Lacey is putting forth a theory of punishments which places the values of the community at its center. This seems to be at strong contrast to contemporary American values where punishment is focused more so on the individual being wronged, in my opinion. I bring Lacey's idea up as it seemed very applicable to the current situation on Mt. Hood this week with the lost climbers. While the context is slightly different, it seems like there is a conversation taking place around punishment and individuals in relationship to the death of the hikers. If you look at the link of the article on OPB's website and read through the comments, there are an amazing amount of comments about the tax cost of search and rescue and whether or not beacons are to be required. Some have stated that Search and Rescue is a Right; while others are saying that individuals who take risks get what is coming to them. What I didn't see was the integration of Lacey's insight that maybe we should shift our scope to larger than the liberal values (to be read as individualistic, like libertarianism) espoused in the comments on OPB's website that would include a communal assessment of Search & Rescue and then making a more pluralistic statement about the cost of Search & Rescue. While this situation is a little different in that it is not a crime (although there is discussion of making it a crime not to climb without a transponder), there is the view that if an individual harms (costs money) by choices, what acts will the community or community not do.
What are the values of our community (Portland) in regards to climbing and outdoor activities? What punishments/laws would support those communal values?
Ought there be a punishment to the individual for poor choices that puts themselves at risk, in the legal system?
Is it really possible to punish individuals and maintain pluralism in a society?
"A conception of punishment as a social practice within a community, geared towards the pursuit of (which entails respect for) a plurality of the community’s central goals and values, moderate in its severity, and with an importantly symbolic aspect. It has both particular (preventive, deterrent and so on) and general (support of the community and its framework values) functions... In constructing the community conception of punishment, despite our relaxation of certain important liberal assumptions and our rejection of some central liberal values, we have been able to preserve and utilise important aspects of the arguments about legal and political obligation and the nature of the criminal law set out in the earlier chapters which integrated the question of punishment in its proper political context." - Nicola Lacey (Professor of Criminal Law and Legal Theory at the London School of Economics).
Before I get into Lacey's quote, I want to point out that this philosopher is alive, teaching and writing at the London School of Economics, although she does not have a Wikipedia page yet. I was introduced to her by chance and read a book by her State Punishment: Political Principles and Community Values.
Lacey's primary argument, as indicated in the quote, is a turn from looking at the need of punishment in a society from an individual focus to a community focus. Lacey is putting forth a theory of punishments which places the values of the community at its center. This seems to be at strong contrast to contemporary American values where punishment is focused more so on the individual being wronged, in my opinion. I bring Lacey's idea up as it seemed very applicable to the current situation on Mt. Hood this week with the lost climbers. While the context is slightly different, it seems like there is a conversation taking place around punishment and individuals in relationship to the death of the hikers. If you look at the link of the article on OPB's website and read through the comments, there are an amazing amount of comments about the tax cost of search and rescue and whether or not beacons are to be required. Some have stated that Search and Rescue is a Right; while others are saying that individuals who take risks get what is coming to them. What I didn't see was the integration of Lacey's insight that maybe we should shift our scope to larger than the liberal values (to be read as individualistic, like libertarianism) espoused in the comments on OPB's website that would include a communal assessment of Search & Rescue and then making a more pluralistic statement about the cost of Search & Rescue. While this situation is a little different in that it is not a crime (although there is discussion of making it a crime not to climb without a transponder), there is the view that if an individual harms (costs money) by choices, what acts will the community or community not do.
What are the values of our community (Portland) in regards to climbing and outdoor activities? What punishments/laws would support those communal values?
Ought there be a punishment to the individual for poor choices that puts themselves at risk, in the legal system?
Is it really possible to punish individuals and maintain pluralism in a society?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)