Showing posts with label aristotle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aristotle. Show all posts

Monday, December 21, 2009

TPF 6 - 21.12.09 - Happiness as a Purpose?

(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)

------------------------------------

Last night I shared a wonderful evening with some friends. We spent hours talking with no agenda, no goal, no direction. The moment took us and I enjoyed the conversations we had. The evening ended by another hour conversation in the wee hours of the morning on a sidewalk that included themes of happiness, doing what is best for oneself, knowing oneself, and how the hell do you know what to do in life? As I laid down to go to sleep (and delay writing the fix till today) I was wondering: what is happiness? is it a noble goal to strive for happiness? These simple questions seem daunting to me and so today I am going to offer a couple quotes and probably a little more of my opinion on the topic than I have in the past.


Aristotle is proposing that happiness is the aspiration of life and the purpose of our existence. I would say this is in alignment with a lot of common day expressions and our (American) culture. You hear it in statements like: "I just want him to be happy." or "I want us to be happy." or "You need to do what is going to make you happy." The first immediate question this brings up, for me, is what the hell is happiness? How do I know if I have reached it? I will tackle those questions a little more tomorrow, but for today; I want to stay with the question: "Is happiness a worthy goal of life?"

Aristotle's argued that to evaluate ethics one must look to the proper function of a thing. That is to say, that if I want to know if a chair is "good" I would look to the function of the chair of holding a sitting person. This same principle he applied to humans and claimed that happiness or well-being was achieved if a person fulfilled their proper function, which for Aristotle required having a good and moral character. Further, he proposed that a person who was able to align their practical knowledge and their intellect (a kind of authenticity) where one consistently chooses the best things would be ethical and wise. This opens up all kinds of questions around what is good, what is best, what is choice,etc. The aspect that I want to focus on today is that Aristotle seemed to have assumed that happiness is a noble goal; something that I believe to be a commonly accepted belief without examination. Seriously, at face value, what could be possibly wrong with happiness being the goal or aspiration of one's life? I am not so sure about this.

I would offer that happiness as the aim of life, as Aristotle proposes, has some problems. It seems it reduces the purpose of life to only a part of the human experience. I use to joke that if happiness is the goal; why don't we all just sit in chairs with morphine drips. I would offer that our culture may not be to far from this with the extent of people who are medicated to be happy (anti-depressants, alcohol, drugs, shopping). It seems that in continuing to put happiness as the purpose of life, and without the context of the process of achieving as Aristotle (or other thinkers have offered), the goal can quickly become harmful. Maybe this is a linguistic confusion where happiness and pleasure have been mistakenly interchanged.

  • Is happiness the purpose of life, or is it one purpose/goal of life that ought to be in balance with others? What other purposes/goals would those be?
  • Is pleasure and happiness the same thing? If not, how are they different?
  • What is the process of attaining happiness for you?