Wednesday, December 16, 2009

TPF 3 - 16.12.09 - Intrinsic vs. Instrumental Value in Copenhagen

Over the last few days I have been listening to NPR and reading reports from Copenhagen Climate Talks. There have been questions of who is responsible, who should bear the weight of the cost of protecting the climate, etc. NPR had a piece on that was interesting that discussed the financial interests of each government in the Climate Talks which got me thinking about a fundamental disagreement that seems to play out when issues of environmental debates come up. There seems to be an underlying view in environmental debates around the instrumental versus the intrinsic value of the environment.

Something has instrumental value if and only if it has value as a means to promote some ends.

Something has intrinsic value (or non-instrumental value) if and only if it has value regardless of whether it is also useful as a means to promote some other ends.

It seems from most of the news I have heard the discussion around Copenhagen is discussing instrumental value. For example, the cost of environmental change, the cost of not changing carbon emissions, etc. Environmentalism has seemed to found a way into the debate now that it has an instrumental value (economics primarily). This discussion I heard from NPR beautifully captured the rub between those who are primarily (or only) concerned with instrumental value versus those concerned with intrinsic value.

Economically Speaking Is Climate Change A Priority?

KESTENBAUM: Now, there are things economics is good at putting a price on and things it is not so good at. I asked him. What is the economic value of the world's last polar bear?

Mr. LOMBORG: I'm not going to answer, you know, I'm not...

KESTENBAUM: I want a dollar figure.

This short exchange between Lomborg and Kestenbaum is grounded in a long philosophical debate between how to evaluate intrinsic value and instrumental value. The question and the fundamental belief that things need to be evaluated in instrumental value continues a branch of philosophy from the turn of the century, specifically Logical Positivism.

"A moral proposition as such - i.e. a proposition to the effect that a certain action represents a supreme value - cannot be said to be either true or false." - Axel Hägerström (Swedish Philosopher, 1868-1939).

Hägerström is proposing that there are no moral propositions since science is not able to evaluate them. Ultimately, Hägerström (along with individuals like Kestenbaum) are proposing that there are no intrinsic values, or at least that intrinsic values can not be known and thus are irrelevant in evaluating what one ought to do. Other philosophers have argued against the logical positivists and Hägerström; but their ideals continue in the debates in Copenhagen and in what people consider to be "valid" arguments for protecting the environment. One doesn't need to travel to Copenhagen to hear arguments similar to Hägerström's. The environmental debates seem to revolve around instrumental value; but what would it take to change this? I wonder what would it take for individuals like Kestenbaum to hear an argument of stewardship that wasn't reduced to instrumental value. To evaluate intrinsic value in the conversation would to introduce ethics and moral debates. Is there room for ethical and moral debates in Copenhagen?

Is it possible to evaluate both instrumental value and intrinsic value when making environmental policy decisions?

Does either intrinsic or instrumental value take precedence over the other in Copenhagen? Should it?

Should governmental policy debate ethics, or is Hägerström insightful in rejecting value/ethical/moral statements because they can not be said to be either true or false?

No comments:

Post a Comment