Wednesday, January 13, 2010

TPF 10 - 14.1.10 - Philosophy of Science / Haiti - Feyerabend

Please email me philosophyfix@gmail.com if you want to be on the email list.

(
http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Late yesterday Haiti was severely damaged by an earthquake. I found out this morning listening to NPR on World Have Your Say. The discussion today had a peculiar juxtaposition between a sense of urgency as you could hear cellphones ringing in the background as people tried to make contact with loved ones with the host discussing with guests of the show on the media coverage of the earthquake. Following the WHYS twitter, Heba posted that a woman left as the discussion was too emotional. I found myself a bit upset at the intellectualizing of media coverage while people sat staring at their phones waiting for a phone call to know if loved ones were alive or not.

A few months ago, I was sitting in a room of therapists. The conversation turned to new technology and ways of communication. I mentioned how I thought twitter was absolutely amazing as it gave people a voice that in the past never had. All that was required was a cell phone and you can text and receive texts of twitters. This meant people could report their world and experiences directly. The responses I got back was that it was a "waste of time," "I don't care if someone is washing their dishes," and "the amount you can tweet is too little to be useful." I mention this today, because most of the immediate communication coming out of Haiti was via Facebook and Twitter because power, phone lines, and other infrastructure was down. To think the power of one tweet coming out of Haiti from one family member to another: "I am alive." (Well under the length limit of a tweet).

What does this all have to do with Philosophy?

"Everywhere science is enriched by unscientific methods and unscientific results, ... the separation of science and non-science is not only artificial but also detrimental to the advancement of knowledge. If we want to understand nature, if we want to master our physical surroundings, then we must use all ideas, all methods, and not just a small selection of them." - Paul Feyerabend (1924-1994, Austrian-American Philosopher of Science).

Today (the 13th of January) was Feyerabend's birthday and so I thought I would include his insights into today's world events. Feyerabend was historically situated writing in the time of the Logical Positivists. The Positivists were a school of empiricism that proclaimed a proposition is "cognitively meaningful" only if there is a finite procedure for conclusively determining whether it is true or false. In otherwords, a statement (like: "I am hungry") is only cognitively meaningful if there was a finite and measurable way to determine my state of hunger. It goes without saying that Feyerabend opposed this view when we look at his quote for today. Feyerabend is challenging the idea that there is one scientific way (or empirical way) to determine something; and instead Feyerabend argued that it was precisely the construct of theories and scientific ideologies that are in contrast to one another or inconsistent with one another. Feyerabend was critical of any method that judged scientific theories in their correspondence with facts. Instead, Feyerabend argued that it was "scientific pluralism" that improved the critical power of science.

What does this all have to do with Haiti and Twitter? We often seem to go through our lives evaluating the empirical value of something where we are individually situated (much like the therapists in my above discussion). Who knew that twitter and Facebook would be more than a simple way to stay in touch; but an infrastructure of information dissemination itself. Ultimately, a critical tool in the attempts of relief aid in communicating information in and out of Haiti. If we do not question the empirical value of things outside the given facts of today; we (as Feyerabend has argued and today's events empirically have indicated) seem to minimize or lose some of the power that science and development has to offer. Feyerabend, in his time, torn down theories of epistemology and philosophy of Science, but in doing so, he created room for new thoughts and theories. This is, in my opinion, what being a philosopher and philosophizing is about. To be receptive of new ways of thought, no matter how far fetched or outrageous they may seem.

With that, my thoughts go out to Haiti and the Haitians who tonight, while I write this intellectual investigation are struggling to stay alive, find loved ones and/or simply survive till tomorrow. For that reason, I leave you with three questions Feyerabend posed to a class he taught in Sussex in 1974:

- What's so great about knowledge?
- What's so great about science?
- What's so great about truth?

1 comment:

  1. First off, the most amazing thing about Twitter / Facebook is when friends get together and can talk about things going on in their lives, ask questions of each other, all knowing a shared subtext. So we know more about each other and, at least in our group, actually care more about each other, because we share experiences. I find that immensely powerful.

    I have a friend that I respect immensely. A former co-worker. He is of the philosophy that since corporations are checking people on Facebook to make sure they're not crazy troublemakers, that it's best not to post anything but the most minimal on Facebook. And even then, nothing personal or contraversial. I disagree with him, but I also find his point of view sad. He's saying that in a world increasingly becoming connected to the point of an oversaturation of information, it's best to unplug to protect your corporate identity. I'd like to think my humor, my empathy and all that I am is what makes me valuable. I don't ascribe to his world view. I'm joining the future.

    That's the great thing about knowledge. Whether it be academic or simply personal or cultural, knowledge brings you in touch with the community and history. Especially if it's true. Then you find yourself not only sharing experiences, but through these shared experiences modern meaning is created. As I've mentioned in the past, real meaning is hard to attain in the hyperreality we live in. So shared experiences constituting a shared meaning is what we have instead. One could see that as sad and meaningless. I believe it's the only place we can find meaning without dismantling the whole system.

    So as I said earlier, I will choose to march boldly into the system instead of fighting it. That's where all my friends are, after all.

    ReplyDelete