Wednesday, January 13, 2010

TPF 10 - 14.1.10 - Philosophy of Science / Haiti - Feyerabend

Please email me philosophyfix@gmail.com if you want to be on the email list.

(
http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Late yesterday Haiti was severely damaged by an earthquake. I found out this morning listening to NPR on World Have Your Say. The discussion today had a peculiar juxtaposition between a sense of urgency as you could hear cellphones ringing in the background as people tried to make contact with loved ones with the host discussing with guests of the show on the media coverage of the earthquake. Following the WHYS twitter, Heba posted that a woman left as the discussion was too emotional. I found myself a bit upset at the intellectualizing of media coverage while people sat staring at their phones waiting for a phone call to know if loved ones were alive or not.

A few months ago, I was sitting in a room of therapists. The conversation turned to new technology and ways of communication. I mentioned how I thought twitter was absolutely amazing as it gave people a voice that in the past never had. All that was required was a cell phone and you can text and receive texts of twitters. This meant people could report their world and experiences directly. The responses I got back was that it was a "waste of time," "I don't care if someone is washing their dishes," and "the amount you can tweet is too little to be useful." I mention this today, because most of the immediate communication coming out of Haiti was via Facebook and Twitter because power, phone lines, and other infrastructure was down. To think the power of one tweet coming out of Haiti from one family member to another: "I am alive." (Well under the length limit of a tweet).

What does this all have to do with Philosophy?

"Everywhere science is enriched by unscientific methods and unscientific results, ... the separation of science and non-science is not only artificial but also detrimental to the advancement of knowledge. If we want to understand nature, if we want to master our physical surroundings, then we must use all ideas, all methods, and not just a small selection of them." - Paul Feyerabend (1924-1994, Austrian-American Philosopher of Science).

Today (the 13th of January) was Feyerabend's birthday and so I thought I would include his insights into today's world events. Feyerabend was historically situated writing in the time of the Logical Positivists. The Positivists were a school of empiricism that proclaimed a proposition is "cognitively meaningful" only if there is a finite procedure for conclusively determining whether it is true or false. In otherwords, a statement (like: "I am hungry") is only cognitively meaningful if there was a finite and measurable way to determine my state of hunger. It goes without saying that Feyerabend opposed this view when we look at his quote for today. Feyerabend is challenging the idea that there is one scientific way (or empirical way) to determine something; and instead Feyerabend argued that it was precisely the construct of theories and scientific ideologies that are in contrast to one another or inconsistent with one another. Feyerabend was critical of any method that judged scientific theories in their correspondence with facts. Instead, Feyerabend argued that it was "scientific pluralism" that improved the critical power of science.

What does this all have to do with Haiti and Twitter? We often seem to go through our lives evaluating the empirical value of something where we are individually situated (much like the therapists in my above discussion). Who knew that twitter and Facebook would be more than a simple way to stay in touch; but an infrastructure of information dissemination itself. Ultimately, a critical tool in the attempts of relief aid in communicating information in and out of Haiti. If we do not question the empirical value of things outside the given facts of today; we (as Feyerabend has argued and today's events empirically have indicated) seem to minimize or lose some of the power that science and development has to offer. Feyerabend, in his time, torn down theories of epistemology and philosophy of Science, but in doing so, he created room for new thoughts and theories. This is, in my opinion, what being a philosopher and philosophizing is about. To be receptive of new ways of thought, no matter how far fetched or outrageous they may seem.

With that, my thoughts go out to Haiti and the Haitians who tonight, while I write this intellectual investigation are struggling to stay alive, find loved ones and/or simply survive till tomorrow. For that reason, I leave you with three questions Feyerabend posed to a class he taught in Sussex in 1974:

- What's so great about knowledge?
- What's so great about science?
- What's so great about truth?

Monday, January 11, 2010

TPF 9 - 11.1.10 - What is a good movie? - Zizek


Please email me philosophyfix@gmail.com if you want to be on the email list.

(
http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Last week I was sitting at Cheer Monday with a bunch of my friends and we were discussing movies, both good movies and bad movies. As it often goes when movies get discussed in a group; a debate erupted about whether a specific movie was good or not. The consequence of this was people attempting to convince the group that the movie they liked or disliked was good or not. This brings me to an area of philosophy that I have done very little with, Aesthetics. One of the most known works on Aesthetics is Critique of Judgement, by Immanual Kant. Aesthetics is the study of beauty, art and taste; so in this context the discussion revolved around the aesthetics of a movie, what people thought was a good movie.

"Cinema is the ultimate pervert art. It doesn't give you what you desire - it tells you how to desire." - Slavoj Žižek (Continental Philosopher, 1949 - Present)

Zizek doesn't offer the foundational analysis of taste in aesthetics that Kant does; he is interested in interpreting meaning of movies and what are movies attempting to do in relationship to our fictional world and reality (foreground and background). He argues that the fictional world is required for us to have reality; and without the fictional world reality would not exist for the human experience (which is why he critiques the Matrix's Blue Pill vs. Red Pill and wants a third pill).

The reason I chose Zizek for today is that I felt he offers a very interesting post-modern view of cinema and politics. And that is exactly what was happening in my discussion last Monday. There was a political aspect to the discussion of what was a good movie. The context of the film, when we saw the film, where we saw the film, what was happening in our lives when we saw the film. This led me to ask the question: "Have you seen a movie that changed your life? If so, what movie?"

The answers were very interesting as they corresponded deeply with where the viewer was situated in their life when they saw the movie. In some cases, a life changing film did not necessarily correspond with the viewer thinking the movie was a good move or one of the best movies. In some cases, while the movie was life changing (upon reflection) the movie was perceived to be silly or not very good.

This got me thinking about Zizek's quote and what makes a good movie. Is a good movie a movie that changes us? Is a good movie something that allows us to escape reality for a bit into the fictional? Is a good movie something that simply entertains? Or is a good movie, a movie that a viewer can relate to? According to Zizek, it is the human experience to have all these intersect.

- What movie, if any, has changed your life? Is it a good movie?
- Is a movie that is good today, necessarily good in a year, five years, or ten years? Or is it situated in its socio-historical context?
- How would you define "Movie of the year?" What qualities would be important?

As a side note, Zizek has a documentary out called The Pervert's Guide to Cinema and, in my opinion, has a great assessment and commentary of the movie Children of Men.

Saturday, January 9, 2010

TPF 8 - 9.1.10 - Determinism and seeing the future

(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I have been watching the TV Series Flash Forward. If you haven't watched it, I would highly suggest you watch it; as it grapples beautifully with the issue of Determinism vs. Free Will. The show is the investigation of a world wide phenomena where every human collapsed at the exact same time for a little over two minutes. During these two minutes people had flash forwards to six months in the future and experienced those two minutes in the future. When everyone re-awoke the flash forwards all corresponded with one another, meaning if I saw you in my flash forward playing baseball then you were playing baseball in your flash forward and saw me.

I appreciate shows that bring philosophical issues to the fore front; which this show has done. It brings to question, which each character struggles with in their own way, how would one live if they knew the outcome of their lives? By seeing the future in six months, does that necessitate that while we experience our lives as making choices; in reality we are actually just responding to stimulus in a predictable manner?

"There is no mind absolute or free will, but the mind is determined for willing this or that by a cause which is determined in its turn by another cause, and this one again by another, and so on to infinity." - Baruch Spinoza (Dutch Philosopher, 1632-1677).

Spinoza is arguing that human actions are done due to the proceeding circumstances, not due to intent or agency. Spinoza, in this sense, is a hard determinism in his argument that purpose of action is an illusion and instead individuals act purely out of proceeding occurrences that cause what an individual will do.

Flash Forward does an interesting job of spinning this philosophical discussion by changing the way in which we would look at determinism. Normally, the question hinges around if we are able to figure out the human machine well enough; we then will be able to ascertain what a person will do given their history by causation. The TV Show instead takes determinism as a plausible position by projecting a future (which is shared among all members of the world, giving it legitimacy and a sense of reality) in which defines where a person will be. The struggle the characters ensue after this is questioning what is it that will lead them to that future? I found it interesting in the show that some individuals lost motivation knowing their future and other gained motivation from knowing their future.

- Is the ability to determine a humans behavior reducible to their previous experiences?
- If you saw your future and you had evidence that it was legitimate; would it change the way you lived?

Monday, January 4, 2010

TPF 7 - 4.1.10 - What is Happiness?

(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)

------------------------------------

Okay, so I haven't been able to keep up and make this as daily as I wanted. I have spent the last two weeks on vacation with family and celebrating the holidays. While on vacation I went to Disneyland, The Happiest Place on Earth. My wife reminded me many times, while entertaining, it was by far not the happiest place on earth. I kept thinking as I wandered around Disneyland (feeling guilty that I left the PhilosophyFix hanging with the question: "What is Happiness?") what would be the happiest place?

"But what is happiness except the simple harmony between a man and the life he leads?" - Albert Camus (French Philosopher, 1913-1960).

I know I already quoted Camus, but I would like to honor his contributions to philosophy in acknowledging his death on January 4th, 1960. I have been interested in Camus' analysis of power and systems of power and their relationship to individual freedom. While Camus rejected being an existentialist and being tied to Sartre; the quote I used today aligns with the idea of authenticity I referenced in the previous fix. The idea that happiness is found in an alignment (or harmony) of who a person is and what a person does.

As with all philosophical endeavor, these statements bring the need to define and clarify. Who a person is, as I am referencing here, is the concept of how a person perceives them self. If I see myself as a "good friend", then this is who "I am."

The life a person leads (or what a person does) is how a person acts in the world and gets reflected back to them by others. So if I am cruel to Others, they will cease being close to me and trusting me. There is a misalignment of "who I am" and "who I am reflected as." This incongruence (or congruence) seems to be at the heart of what Camus is getting at for obtaining happiness.

I walked through Disneyland and perceived this rub. Parents with their children. Its Disneyland. I am a happy parent, with a happy child in a happy land; but my child is crying and people are looking at me. I find it interesting that going somewhere that is advertised as the happiest place on earth sets the expectation that one should be "happy," but without any deeper context of what that means. I found Disneyland entertaining, extravagant, fun, and distracting from the stresses of my "normal" life; but my wife was correct in pointing out that it was not a place of happiness. It might have been more accurate to call Disneyland the most entertaining, or most distracting from life's worries, or even the most pleasurable place on earth.

I wonder what Walt and Albert would have had to say to one another if they had the chance to discuss happiness with one another.

“People look at you and me to see what they are supposed to be. And if we don’t disappoint them, then maybe, just maybe, they won’t disappoint us.” - Walt Disney (Entertainer, philanthropist, entrepreneur, 1901-1966).

I think Walt and Albert might disagree where people look (or should look) to in defining who they are suppose to be.

"You will never be happy if you continue to search for what happiness consists of. You will never live if you are looking for the meaning of life." - Albert Camus

Maybe Camus is right.... I shouldn't travel looking for happiness; I didn't find it at Disneyland.

  • So what is Happiness?
  • Where should one look to define who they are?
  • Is happiness tied to congruence between who we believe (or want to be) and who we are in the world?

Monday, December 21, 2009

TPF 6 - 21.12.09 - Happiness as a Purpose?

(http://philosophyfix.blogspot.com - if you want to comment or discuss with others)

------------------------------------

Last night I shared a wonderful evening with some friends. We spent hours talking with no agenda, no goal, no direction. The moment took us and I enjoyed the conversations we had. The evening ended by another hour conversation in the wee hours of the morning on a sidewalk that included themes of happiness, doing what is best for oneself, knowing oneself, and how the hell do you know what to do in life? As I laid down to go to sleep (and delay writing the fix till today) I was wondering: what is happiness? is it a noble goal to strive for happiness? These simple questions seem daunting to me and so today I am going to offer a couple quotes and probably a little more of my opinion on the topic than I have in the past.


Aristotle is proposing that happiness is the aspiration of life and the purpose of our existence. I would say this is in alignment with a lot of common day expressions and our (American) culture. You hear it in statements like: "I just want him to be happy." or "I want us to be happy." or "You need to do what is going to make you happy." The first immediate question this brings up, for me, is what the hell is happiness? How do I know if I have reached it? I will tackle those questions a little more tomorrow, but for today; I want to stay with the question: "Is happiness a worthy goal of life?"

Aristotle's argued that to evaluate ethics one must look to the proper function of a thing. That is to say, that if I want to know if a chair is "good" I would look to the function of the chair of holding a sitting person. This same principle he applied to humans and claimed that happiness or well-being was achieved if a person fulfilled their proper function, which for Aristotle required having a good and moral character. Further, he proposed that a person who was able to align their practical knowledge and their intellect (a kind of authenticity) where one consistently chooses the best things would be ethical and wise. This opens up all kinds of questions around what is good, what is best, what is choice,etc. The aspect that I want to focus on today is that Aristotle seemed to have assumed that happiness is a noble goal; something that I believe to be a commonly accepted belief without examination. Seriously, at face value, what could be possibly wrong with happiness being the goal or aspiration of one's life? I am not so sure about this.

I would offer that happiness as the aim of life, as Aristotle proposes, has some problems. It seems it reduces the purpose of life to only a part of the human experience. I use to joke that if happiness is the goal; why don't we all just sit in chairs with morphine drips. I would offer that our culture may not be to far from this with the extent of people who are medicated to be happy (anti-depressants, alcohol, drugs, shopping). It seems that in continuing to put happiness as the purpose of life, and without the context of the process of achieving as Aristotle (or other thinkers have offered), the goal can quickly become harmful. Maybe this is a linguistic confusion where happiness and pleasure have been mistakenly interchanged.

  • Is happiness the purpose of life, or is it one purpose/goal of life that ought to be in balance with others? What other purposes/goals would those be?
  • Is pleasure and happiness the same thing? If not, how are they different?
  • What is the process of attaining happiness for you?

Friday, December 18, 2009

TPF 5 - 18.12.09 - Philosophy as a Social Engagement


"Philosophy: A route of many roads leading from nowhere to nothing." - Ambroce Bierce (1942-1914, Journalist)

While Ambroce Bierce isn't a philosopher, per se, it seemed appropriate to end the week with a quote of his. I have had some people ask about where to comment on the PhilosophyFix. I started this week with asking, "What is Philosophy?" Philosophy is an activity of engagement, I believe. This quote by Bierce, I believe, aligns well with what Wittgenstein stated in TPF 1, that it is an activity. Bierce adds the sense that philosophy is a journal of multiple paths and in this sense, I believe this includes multiple perspectives and people (although I don't believe Bierce thought of it in this way)l It is best when discourse and the many roads are explored. The Philosophy Fix is just a start of those roads. I am interested in what people think and hope people share their thoughts with one another. You can post comments on the blog: philosophyfix.blogspot.com; but if anyone has a better idea of how to have discussions/comments I would like to hear them.

Have a good weekend.

What is a good weekend?

How would I know if my weekend was good?

Thursday, December 17, 2009

TPF 4 - 17.12.09 - Punishment

In the process of coming up with this fix, a friend of mine said he hoped that I wouldn't just use the same philosophers that I always quote (Nietzsche, Sartre, etc.) but instead branch out more and quote other philosophers. This poses one benefit and one challenge. The benefit is that I get an opportunity to go read philosophers I am not acquainted with as well (like in yesterday's TPF). The challenge is that philosophy is built upon philosophy. As I read over a few books today, I realized that the amount of name dropping and reference to other philosophers is quite common. Originally I had hoped to write about the stalling tactics today in the Senate and specifically in the context of authenticity. While an interesting topic and one worth exploration, I chose not to because most of the references I wanted to quote referenced many other philosophers. So today, I am going to write about how philosophy is still alive and in a very real way.

"A conception of punishment as a social practice within a community, geared towards the pursuit of (which entails respect for) a plurality of the community’s central goals and values, moderate in its severity, and with an importantly symbolic aspect. It has both particular (preventive, deterrent and so on) and general (support of the community and its framework values) functions... In constructing the community conception of punishment, despite our relaxation of certain important liberal assumptions and our rejection of some central liberal values, we have been able to preserve and utilise important aspects of the arguments about legal and political obligation and the nature of the criminal law set out in the earlier chapters which integrated the question of punishment in its proper political context." - Nicola Lacey (Professor of Criminal Law and Legal Theory at the London School of Economics).

Before I get into Lacey's quote, I want to point out that this philosopher is alive, teaching and writing at the London School of Economics, although she does not have a Wikipedia page yet. I was introduced to her by chance and read a book by her State Punishment: Political Principles and Community Values.

Lacey's primary argument, as indicated in the quote, is a turn from looking at the need of punishment in a society from an individual focus to a community focus. Lacey is putting forth a theory of punishments which places the values of the community at its center. This seems to be at strong contrast to contemporary American values where punishment is focused more so on the individual being wronged, in my opinion. I bring Lacey's idea up as it seemed very applicable to the current situation on Mt. Hood this week with the lost climbers. While the context is slightly different, it seems like there is a conversation taking place around punishment and individuals in relationship to the death of the hikers. If you look at the link of the article on OPB's website and read through the comments, there are an amazing amount of comments about the tax cost of search and rescue and whether or not beacons are to be required. Some have stated that Search and Rescue is a Right; while others are saying that individuals who take risks get what is coming to them. What I didn't see was the integration of Lacey's insight that maybe we should shift our scope to larger than the liberal values (to be read as individualistic, like libertarianism) espoused in the comments on OPB's website that would include a communal assessment of Search & Rescue and then making a more pluralistic statement about the cost of Search & Rescue. While this situation is a little different in that it is not a crime (although there is discussion of making it a crime not to climb without a transponder), there is the view that if an individual harms (costs money) by choices, what acts will the community or community not do.

What are the values of our community (Portland) in regards to climbing and outdoor activities? What punishments/laws would support those communal values?

Ought there be a punishment to the individual for poor choices that puts themselves at risk, in the legal system?

Is it really possible to punish individuals and maintain pluralism in a society?